The short answer: same bag, different neutral
The Aspen and Birch Classic Diaper Bag II are the same design in two colorways. Every functional detail—pockets, straps, materials, dimensions—is identical across both. So the decision comes down to which neutral you want to carry every day, not which bag holds more or organizes better.
That’s good news: you can pick the color that fits your wardrobe and lifestyle without sacrificing any of the organization features that make the Classic Diaper Bag II a practical choice.
What both colorways share
- Birch Classic Diaper Bag II: 12 pockets with a spacious central compartment for larger items The pocket count and central space are the same in Aspen and Birch, so organization isn’t a differentiator.
Birch Classic Diaper Bag II - Aspen Classic Diaper Bag II: Wearable 3 ways: backpack, cross-body, or purse Carry flexibility is identical, so you can choose your color based on style without losing versatility.

Aspen Classic Diaper Bag II - Birch Classic Diaper Bag II: Premium quality vegan leather with wipeable and stain-resistant nylon interior lining Both colors use the same materials, so care and durability are the same.
- Aspen Classic Diaper Bag II: 13" wide x 15" high x 7" deep The dimensions are the same, so capacity and fit on your frame won’t vary by color.
Why color still matters
Even though the bags are functionally identical, the color you choose affects how the bag fits into your daily life. A lighter neutral like Birch can feel fresh and blend with summer outfits, while a deeper neutral like Aspen may show less everyday wear and pair easily with darker clothing. Neither is better—it’s about what you’ll reach for most.
Questions to ask before you decide
- What’s in your closet?: Look at the coats, jackets, and strollers you use most. A neutral that complements those items will feel more cohesive.
- How often will you clean it?: Both interiors and exteriors are wipeable and spill resistant, but lighter colors may show scuffs sooner. If you prefer low-maintenance, a deeper neutral might suit you.
- Will you carry it as a purse?: The bag wears three ways, so if you plan to use it as an everyday purse, pick the color that matches your usual handbags.
- Do you want it to stand out or blend in?: A lighter neutral can read more summery and casual; a darker one can look more formal. Consider where you’ll take it most.
A note on care and longevity
Both Aspen and Birch feature the same wipeable, stain-resistant materials and metal feet on the bottom to keep the bag off the ground. The changing pad is machine washable. Since the materials are identical, your care routine won’t change with color—just wipe clean as needed and follow the supplied care instructions.
Details that are the same in both
- Birch Classic Diaper Bag II: Insulated interior pocket Keeps bottles cool in either color, so temperature control isn’t a factor in your choice.
- Aspen Classic Diaper Bag II: Interior 6" keyclip You’ll never lose your keys, regardless of which neutral you pick.
- Birch Classic Diaper Bag II: Padded adjustable straps Comfort is identical, so you can focus on aesthetics.
- Aspen Classic Diaper Bag II: 2.3 lbs. weight The bag is lightweight in both colors, so carry fatigue won’t differ.
How to make the final call
If you’re still torn, consider the season you’re buying for. A lighter neutral can feel right for spring and summer, while a deeper neutral transitions easily into fall and winter. Or think about the bag’s primary home—if it lives on a stroller in a light-colored nursery, Birch might blend in; if it’s tossed into a dark car, Aspen might hide marks better.
Ultimately, both the Aspen and Birch Classic Diaper Bag II offer the same 12 pockets, wearable three ways, and wipeable materials. Pick the color that makes you smile—you’re not sacrificing function either way.




